Do writers want to see each other's AI prompts in shared editors?
This study explores whether revealing AI prompting activity to collaborators in text editors affects how writers work together. Understanding prompt visibility matters because it shapes trust, learning, and awareness of AI's role in collaborative writing.
The paper tests four levels of prompt visibility inside a shared text editor: sharing nothing, sharing a placeholder that indicates AI use, sharing details about how the resulting text was generated, and sharing everything, including how the prompt was formulated, in real time. Sixteen participants wrote persuasive essays in pairs under all four. The abstract reports "a strong preference for techniques that share more information about prompting activities" and concludes that collaborative editors "should share more information among writers on when, how, and where AI is used." The framing matters: tools like Google Docs and Overleaf already broadcast cursor movements, selections, and edits, but according to the introduction they do not share the prompt that was issued or where its output was used.
The discussion attributes the preference to awareness, and it splits that awareness into three parts. Seeing prompts being formed in real time told participants what a collaborator was doing at that moment. Seeing the prompt together with the original text selection showed how the resulting text was formed, which participants said helped them understand each other's thought process, built trust, and gave them chances to learn from each other. A comment marking AI-generated text signaled where AI was used, which mattered because participants wanted to indicate, and to know, which parts of the document needed additional verification.
The preference is not unanimous, and the paper says so. Some participants held that formulating a prompt should be "private," felt uncomfortable when everything was shared, and worried that their prompts would be judged. The authors also note that awareness of others' prompts "may have influenced each other's thinking in ways they did not appreciate," which some found distracting and annoying. The result is a tradeoff between awareness and self-consciousness, and the introduction anticipates it by noting that shared activity in editors can distract writers and make them feel self-conscious.
This sits alongside notes that treat the AI's contribution as hard to see. Do writers actually edit AI-generated text before publishing? describes AI text traveling onward with little revision. A marker showing where AI was used gives a co-writer a reason to check that text before it travels further. Do users truly own the AI-generated content they produce? describes a gap between claimed and felt authorship, and prompt sharing is one channel through which a collaborator could see the process behind a claim. This paper does not test that link. Can we measure prompt quality independent of model outputs? treats prompts as measurable, which fits the worry that visible prompts become judgeable.
The excerpt is silent on several things. It reports no effect sizes, no measures of essay quality or verification behavior, and nothing on whether trust actually changed. The benefits are what participants said they perceived. Sixteen participants writing persuasive essays in pairs is a small sample on one task, so the excerpt does not show that the preference holds for other writing tasks, larger groups, or working teams. What it supports is narrower: when writers in this setting could see more of a collaborator's prompting, most preferred it, and the cost they named was privacy and judgment rather than lost information. That points toward graded or opt-in disclosure, not an all-or-nothing default, though the excerpt does not test such designs.
Inquiring lines that read this note 56
This note is a source for these research framings, grouped by the broader line of inquiry each explores. Scan the bold lines of inquiry; follow any specific question forward.
Does AI coding assistance improve productivity and code quality across experience levels?- When do students feel authentic ownership of code they co-created with AI?
- How should code authorship be measured in human-AI collaborative development?
- What collaboration model between humans and AI best serves peer review?
- Why should AI research prompts be subject to peer review before use?
- Could hidden prompts be inserted during review and removed before publication?
- How should AI be integrated into creative workflows to protect collective diversity?
- Can collaboration with GenAI preserve long-term skill development in writing work?
- Does AI shift knowledge work away from communication toward solo documentation tasks?
- What makes colleagues willing to share how they actually use GenAI at work?
- What informal learning opportunities vanish when GenAI use stays hidden from colleagues?
- How does disclosure of AI use differ from proof of who did the work?
- What happens to collaborative trust when effort becomes invisible in finished work?
- How does disclosure of AI involvement change across private versus public writing contexts?
- Why do collaborative writers want visibility of AI use while public posters avoid it?
- How do collaborators react when they see detailed AI tool usage logs?
- What makes low-effort work visible enough to damage colleague trust?
- What makes writers feel self-conscious about their prompts in collaborative spaces?
- Does seeing a collaborator's prompt influence how another writer thinks?
- How much do writers actually edit AI text before publishing it?
- Do writers edit AI assistance enough to fool content filters?
- Can explanation-based AI safeguards work in real-time writing interfaces?
- How does hiding AI use from readers differ from showing it to collaborators?
- What tolerance limits exist for AI visibility in shared writing?
- Why do writers hesitate to disclose when they used AI tools?
- Can writers build AI literacy in readers through interface design choices?
- Do writers benefit when they make their AI prompting activity visible to collaborators?
- Why do writers underestimate how much readers want AI disclosure?
- Can readers detect AI involvement in writing when not explicitly told?
- Would reader attitudes toward AI writing change if disclosure were required?
- Does directly copying AI text into writing change disclosure expectations?
- When AI becomes invisible in writing tools, do writers stop disclosing it?
- Does ownership of AI text lead users to rely more on suggestions?
- How do AI tools change the relationship between writing effort and ability signaling?
- What tools or practices help people disclose AI use in their writing?
- Does editing AI drafts build skill or replace skill-building practice?
- Why do writers hide AI use from collaborators while reading shows it matters?
- Why do writers resist disclosing AI use more than readers demand it?
- How do writing assistants balance system initiative versus user control in interaction?
- Which design combinations for writing assistants remain unexplored in current research?
- Why does visual differentiation between user and AI text affect writer trust?
- How do writers verify and revise AI-generated text before sharing it?
- Can text detection methods distinguish between AI collaboration and delegation?
- Why does writing dominate work-related ChatGPT use compared to other tasks?
- How should design roles adapt when prompt artifacts become shared?
- What distinguishes ghost work from traditional academic or paid research collaboration?
- Can open collaboration survive if sharing work-in-progress becomes competitively dangerous?
Related concepts in this collection 4
This note in its neighbourhood — explore the map, then jump to a related concept in the list below.
Click a node to walk · click center to open · click Open in graph to see this note in the full knowledge graph
-
Do writers actually edit AI-generated text before publishing?
This research tests whether the "human-in-the-loop" safeguard against AI text quality issues actually works in practice. It examines how often writers revise AI-generated paragraphs and how substantially they change them.
nearly unedited AI text travels onward, which is why participants wanted AI-marked passages flagged for verification
-
Do users truly own the AI-generated content they produce?
When people use AI to create outputs, do they experience genuine authorship and ownership of what's produced, or does the continuous interaction loop create a gap between what they feel and what they claim?
prompt sharing exposes the process behind declared authorship, an untested link
-
Can we measure prompt quality independent of model outputs?
This explores whether prompt quality has measurable, learnable dimensions beyond intuition. The research asks if prompts can be evaluated by their communicative, cognitive, and instructional properties rather than by their results.
evaluable prompts explain the worry that shared prompts get judged
-
Does ownership framing change how much writers rely on AI?
When writers believe they own the final output versus composing for themselves, do they use AI suggestions differently? Understanding this matters because it reveals whether reliance is driven by tool capability or by how tasks are framed.
shows ownership shapes AI use; this paper concerns whether collaborators can see that use
Related papers in this collection 8
Papers most semantically related to this note, ranked by cosine similarity in the embedding space.
- Show Me Your Prompts! How Writers Feel About Sharing Prompts in Collaborative Text Editors
- Evidence-centered Assessment for Writing with Generative AI
- Penalizing Transparency? How AI Disclosure and Author Demographics Shape Human and AI Judgments About Writing
- Understanding Reader Perception Shifts upon Disclosure of AI Authorship
- What Influences Readers' and Writers' Perceived Necessity of AI Disclosure?
- Does AI Assistance Leave a Temporal Fingerprint? Detecting Overreliance in AI-Assisted Writing and Programming
- The AI Ghostwriter Effect: When Users Do Not Perceive Ownership of AI-Generated Text But Self-Declare as Authors
- GhostWriter: Augmenting Collaborative Human-AI Writing Experiences Through Personalization and Agency
Original note title
writers in collaborative text editors prefer sharing more prompting activity with collaborators because it shows when, how, and where AI was used